Visa Inc (NYSE:V) remains the undisputed scale leader in the payments industry, but Mastercard Inc (NYSE:MA) has been outpacing its rival in growth.

Should investors bet on Visa's dominance or Mastercard's momentum?

JPMorgan's Tien-tsin Huang analyzes the key differences between the two payment giants, focusing on their financials, shareholder returns, and valuation dynamics.

Scale Vs. Speed: Who Wins?

Visa's dominance is clear — it boasts 63% more total volume, 31% more revenue, and an enviable ten-point operating margin advantage, thanks to superior fixed cost leverage. It also has 50% more cards outstanding and commands nearly two-thirds of the global market share in purchase volume.

However, Mastercard has been running circles around Visa in growth, capitalizing on a mix of faster-expanding regions and revenue streams. According to Huang, Mastercard outpaced Visa in revenue growth by about two percentage points, maintaining its five-year average edge. Even on the bottom line, Mastercard's adjusted EPS grew four percentage points faster, thanks to margin expansion—something Visa couldn't pull off last year.

Read Also: Stripe's Payment Surge Puts Adyen, PayPal, Fiserv On Notice – AI, Stablecoins Fuel The Race

Shareholder Returns: A Dead Heat

Both companies are cash flow powerhouses, returning nearly all of their adjusted net income to shareholders via aggressive share buybacks. In 2024, Mastercard and Visa shares gained 23% and 21%, respectively, mirroring the S&P 500's performance.

However, Huang notes that Visa has taken the early lead in 2025, benefiting from investors' appetite for U.S. growth and a reduced regulatory overhang.

The Valuation Puzzle

Network multiples have expanded, with Mastercard trading at 33x forward earnings versus Visa's 28x.

While both remain in line with their historical premium to the S&P 500, Huang points out that Mastercard's higher multiple reflects its stronger growth profile, while Visa's relative value case is gaining traction.

The Verdict

Huang isn't picking sides, maintaining an Overweight rating on both stocks. Mastercard's growth premium looks sustainable, but Visa's relative value and easing regulatory risks could make it the safer bet.

Investors have a choice—go big with Visa or go fast with Mastercard. Either way, it's a battle of titans worth watching.

• Elon Musk Says 'Hang On To Your Stock' In Surprise Late-Evening Tesla All-Hands Meeting — Touts 7 Million EVs, Optimus Robot, And AI Supercomputer Dojo

Image: Shutterstock